Using Health Accounts...To Understand Patterns of Spending

Health accounts, if conducted on annual basis over a period of several years, are invaluable in helping to understand the impact of specific policies on the health care system.  Presented below are examples of how health accounts, by allowing policy-makers to follow patterns of expenditures, goods and services production and utilization over time, and to compare them to achieved health outcome and health care access indicators, can contribute to the formulation of truly effective policies.

Health Finance Reforms

Financing is a critical factor in the realization of a viable health system. It is the mechanism by which plans and policies are translated into action through the allocation of resources. 

Health financing reforms include changes in revenue collection, involving the concept of pooling, and reforms in the purchasing of health services.  Following the impact of these reforms on health expenditure indicators over the years would reveal whether they had the intended effect, and which population and provider groups they impacted the most.

Health finance reforms have largely been driven by a desire to improve access to healthcare, advance equity in health service provision and promote the use of cost-effective technologies in order to obtain the best possible health outcomes for populations.  However, such reforms have also been seen by governments as a means of controlling the costs of health care and of spreading them to other players, especially the users of services.

According to the WHO, in planning health system reforms policy-makers and health planners should address the following key questions:

  • How can sufficient funds be mobilized to finance health services and the required infrastructure?
  • How can those funds be allocated and how can the delivery of health care be organized so that defined needs and priorities are addressed?
  • How can the cost of care be controlled?

For example, in Colombia health accounts indicators helped determine if the health system's per capita spending level established by the planners could be sustained, given the resources available and expenditures incurred, based on a 4-year trend between 1997 and 2000.

Health accounts indicators are used to provide a measure of progress of health finance reforms. Some of the common indicators are: 

  • social spending
  • national expenditure on health
  • coverage of health services
  • production and use of health services
  • intermediate and final consumption of health services and pharmaceutical products
  • gross capital formation
  • exports and imports
  • gross value of production
  • value added of health care services industries
  • employment

The steps that might be taken to reform health financing at a sub-national level (municipal, institution, province), are as follows:

  1. Understand the broad health care financing context.

  2. Map the health system in order to understand the level of current resources and how they are used.

  3. Develop the resource base for health services.

  4. Allocate funds to address planning priorities.

  5. Build budgets for management and accountability.

  6. Purchase health services so as to optimize effectiveness and efficiency.

  7. Develop the infrastructure for the financing of health care.

  8. Use financing as a tool to change the delivery of health services.

  9. Re-examine periodically the impact of financing changes on access to care, quality of services, outcome indicators, and financial indicators.

Sub-Accounts for HIV/AIDS

As of April 2004, National HIV/AIDS accounts have been undertaken in 20 LAC countries with the support from SIDALAC, a regional initiative on HIV/AIDS financed by the World Bank and administered by FUNSALUD. They follow a methodology integrating the OECD SHA and Harvard NHA models (a PDF document in Spanish and English is available for download).

Since the countries have followed the same methodology and have produced data for roughly the same years, an informative international comparison of spending patterns on HIV/AIDS in the region is possible. For example, it has become clear that, although technical experts recommended emphasis on purchasing preventive treatments, a bulk of the expenditures is on curative care.  In light of the information provided by the national HIV/AIDS accounts, the observed HIV/AIDS infection rates in specific countries may point to the effectiveness to specific treatment approaches. A publication on this topic is available at the SIDALAC webpage.

 

Related Links and Articles

Documents
Resource Mobilization for the Health Sector in Bolivia 184 KB, PDF

This report describes Bolivia's experience with resource mobilization for the health sector.

Demographic and Epidemiological Determinants of Healthcare Costs in Netherlands 251 KB, PDF

This article, published in the British Medical Journal in 1998, describes the costs of specific illnesses to the Dutch healthcare system incurred during 1994. The authors emphasize the need to consider changing disease patters when planning cost-containment strategies. 

Economic Evaluations of HIV/AIDS Interventions (Population Council Publications) 200 KB, PDF Economic evaluations of HIV/AIDS interventions provide important information on costs to help program managers budget more effectively. Estimating the cost of service delivery provides insights on how well resources are being managed and what can be done to improve efficiency.
Using the National Health Accounts Sub-Analysis to Track Resource Flows for HIV/AIDS This June 2004 PHRplus NHA Global Policy Brief outlines how the NHA methodology can be used to track health expenditures on HIV/AIDS, and how this information can in turn be used for policy decisions.
HIV/AIDS: Its Social and Economic Impact In Colombia 1.94MB, PDF The socioeconomic research in this paper, supported by Family Health International, was carried out in order to detail the impact of the HIV/AIDS epidemic and to indicate future needs in terms of both prevention and treatment.
Cost Effectiveness of HIV Prevention in Developing Countries 75 KB, PDF HIV/AIDS prevention interventions in developing countries can reduce the incidence of HIV infection and sometimes save financial resources in the process.
Organizations
GTZ This website describes GTZ's HIV/AIDS activities in general and in the projects.You will also find a summary about the current HIV/AIDS situation in the world,  information about "good practices" of prevention and control, and a database with recommended readings including GTZ publications.
International AIDS Economics Network IAEN focuses on the economics of HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment, providing data, tools, and analysis for researchers and policymakers working to define and implement effective AIDS policy (see their 2002 presentation, 84 KB, PDF)
PHRplus HIV/AIDS Activities The USAID-funded global PHRplus Project employed the National Health Accounts framework and methodology to estimate sero-positive households' utilization and expenditures on health care in Rwanda.
UNAIDS Broad spectrum of resources, including best practices papers
World Health Report (WHR) 2003

The WHR 2003 contains information about how health accounts are used for the essential function of health system stewardship.

Partners IADB logo IADB PAHO logo PAHO USAID logo USAID World Bank logo World Bank

LAC Health Accounts © 2000 - 2004 All rights reserved | Credits
Please direct all comments and questions about these pages to dorotar@iadb.org.